Explaining the Good Governance of Agricultural Surface Water Resources in the Gawshan Watershed Basin, Kermanshah, Iran

Document Type : Original Research

Authors
M. Tatar 1
A. Papzan 1
M. Ahmadvand 2
1 Department of Agricultural Extension and Education, Agricultural College, Razi University, Kermanshah, Islamic Republic of Iran.
2 Department of Rural Development Management, Faculty of Agriculture, Yasouj University, Yasouj, Islamic Republic of Iran.
Abstract
The purpose of this study was to explain the current water governance at Gawshan Watershed Basin in Kermanshah Province and then provide an alternative conceptual framework for good governance of water resources at the basin scale. Participants were selected purposefully among the representatives of rival groups. Participatory workshop technique was used to collect data with the aid of interviews and focus group discussions. Analysis of the interviews led to classification of the challenges of water governance into several categories. These include the lack of participation, fairness, accountability, responsiveness, legitimacy, transparency and consensus-oriented processes. Then, water governance solutions were extracted based on the consensus among the participants. These include farmers’ contribution to decision- making processes regarding agricultural water consumption, empowering the local people to negotiate and manage conflicts, establishing a participatory mechanism to manage water conflict, holding training courses and workshops for staff to get acquainted with the principles of good governance, creating transparent and accessible information system by agricultural water section, and holding education-extension courses to increase information and awareness of the stakeholders in line with responsibility. Finally, a framework for good governance of water resources in the watershed basin was drawn up after linking the concepts.

Keywords

Subjects

1. Andreas, M. R. 2003.Validity and Reliability Tests in Case study Research: A Literature Review with Hands-on Applications for Each Research Phase. Qualit. Market Res: An Int. J., 6(2): 75-86.
2. Balali, M. R., Keulartz, F.W. J. and Korthals, M. 2011. Reflexive Land and Water Management in Iran: Linking Technology, Governance and Culture, Part 2: Stakeholders' Attitudes and the Key Elements of Reflexive Framework. J. of Water Res. in Agr., 24(2): 73-97.
3. Barker, D. 2000. Local Governance: A Model of Sustainable Rural Resource Management for the Third World. Agr. Resour. Govern. and Ecol., 1(1): 43- 55.
4. Barli, O., Baskent, E., Turker, M. and Gedik, T. 2006. Analytical Approach for Analyzing and Providing Solutions for the Conflicts among Forest Stakeholders across Turkey. Forest Policy and Econ., 9(3): 219-236.
5. Bijani, M. and Hayati, D. 2011. Water Conflict in Agricultural System in IRAN: A Human Eecological Analysis. J. of Ecol. and Environ. Sci., 2: 27-40.
6. Bijani, M. and Hayati, D. 2015. Farmers’ Perceptions toward Agricultural Water Conflict: The Case of Doroodzan Dam Irrigation Network, Iran. J. Agr. Sci. Tech., 17(3): 561-575.
7. Blackman, R. 2003. Peace-building Within Our Communities. Root series (Root 4). Tearfund Publishing, UK.
8. Bryman, A. 2001. Social Research Method. London: Oxford University Press.
9. Bundschuh, F. F. 2008. Good Governance: Characteristics, Methods and the Austrian Examples. Transylvanian Review of Administrative Sciences, 26-52.
10. Cernea, M. M. 1993. Culture and Organization: The Social Sustainability of Induced Development. Sustain. Dev., 1(2): 18- 29.
11. Dekker, K. and van Kempen, R. 2004. Urban Governance within the Big Cities Policy: Ideals and Practice in Den Haag, the Netherlands. Cities., 21(2): 109-117.
12. Ghaemi, A., Larijani, M., Shobeiri, M. and Sarmadi, M. 2017. A Conceptual Model for the Sustainable Governance of Integrated Management of National Water Resources with a Focus on Training and Capacity Building. J. of Water and Wastewater, 28(4): 112- 117.
13. Gleick, P. H. and Heberger, M. 2012. Water and Conflict. Events, Trends, and Analysis. The World Water., 8: 159- 171.
14. Gleik P.H. 2014. Water, Drought, Climate Change, and Conflict in Syria. Am. Metric. Soc. J., 6:331- 340.
15. Golafshani, N. 2003. Understanding Reliability and Validity in Qualitative Research. The Qualit. Rep., 8(4): 597-607.
16. Graham, J., Amos, B., Plumptre, T. 2003. Governance Principles for Protected Areas in the 21st Century. Institute On Governance, Ottawa, Canada.
17. Green, B. E. 2002. Sharing Water: A Human Ecological Analysis of the Causes of Conflict and Cooperation Between Nations over Freshwater Resources. The Ohio State University, Dissertation.
18. Guba, E . and Lincoln, Y. 1985. Naturalistic Inquiry, Beverly Hills, CA, Sage.
19. Hadi, S. 2005. Enhancing Local Governance through Decentralization Policy in Managing Conflict- Affected Regions in Indonesia. Paper to be presented at the International Conference on Engaging Communities; UNDESA/UNCRD Workshop on Decentralization: Poverty Reduction, Empowerment and Participation, Brisbane, Australia, 14-17 August, 2005.
20. Hamedinger, A. 2004. The Changing Organization of Spatial Planning in Vienna: learning Lessons from the Organization of Planning in the UK in the Context of the Shift From Government to Governance? Paper presented at the EURA/ UUA conference ‘City Futures’, Chicago, 8-10 July 2004.
21. Heidelberg Institute for International Conflict Research (Department of Political Science, University of Heidelberg). 2007. Conflict Barometer 2007: Crises – Wars – Coups d’Etat – Nagotiations – Mediations – Peace Settlements.
22. Hesam, M., Rezvani, M., and Ashur, H. 2014. Satisfaction of Villagers with Villagers Performance with Good Rural Validity Approach, Case Study: Southern Rural Villages - Gorgan County. Geogr. Spatial. Plann., 4(14): 99-128.
23. Hornby, A. S. 2005. Oxford Advanced Learner’s Dictionary of Current English. Oxford University Press. New York
24. Kooiman, J., Bavinck, M., Jentoft, S. and Pullin, R. 2005. Fish for Life: Interactive Governance for Fisheries. Amsterdam University Press, Amsterdam.
25. Kramer, A. 2004. Water and Conflict. (Policy briefing for USAID). Berlin, Bogor, Washington, DC: Adelphi Research, Center for International Forestry Research, Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars.
26. Lienert, J., Schnetzer, F. and Ingold, K. 2013. Stakeholder Analysis Combined with Social Network Analysis Provides Fine-grained Insights into Water Infrastructure Planning Processes. J. of Environ. Manage., 125: 134-148.
27. Mahab Consulting Engineers Company. 2000. National plan of Gavshan. Review report the temporary diversion systems and flood discharge of Gavshan dam: 1-39
28. Mahon, R., Fanning, L. and McConney, P. 2009. A Governance Perspective on the Large Marine Ecosystem Approach. Mar. Policy, 33: 317–321,
29. Meissner, R. 2016. Paradigms and Theories in Water Governance: The Case of South Africa’s National Water Resource Strategy. Water SA., 42(1): 1-10.
30. Menatizadeh, M., Zamani, G.H. and Gholamrezae, S. 2015. The Analysis of Farmers’ Environmental Moral Norms: The Case of Shiraz County Farmers. Iranian Agr. Ext. & Educ., J., 11(2): 49- 65.
31. Mirzaei, A., Knierima, A., Fealy Nahavand, S. and Mahmoudi, H. 2017. Gap Analysis of Water Governance in Northern Iran: A Closer Look into the Water Reservoirs. Environ. Sci. Policy, 77: 98-106.
32. OECD. 2015. OECD Principles on Water Governance. Welcomed by Ministers at the OECD Ministerial Council Meeting on 4 June 2015.
33. Pandy. P. 2018. Making Innovations Work: Local Government–NGO Partnership and Collaborative Governance in Rural Bangladesh. Dev. in Practice., 28 (1): 125-137.
34. Peeters, L. W., and Ateljevic, I. 2009. Women Empowerment Entrepreneurship Nexus in Tourism: Processes of Social. In J. Ateljevic, & S. J. Page, Tourism and Entrepreneurship: International Perspective. Butterworth-Heinemann.
35. Perlman, J. D., Veilleux, J. C. and Wolf, A. T. 2017. International Water Conflict and Cooperation: Challenges and Opportunities. Water Int., 42(2): 105-120.
36. Rola, A. C., Pulhin, J. M., Tabios, G. Q., Lizada, J. C. and Dayo, M. H. 2015. Challenges of Water Governance in the Philippines. Philippine J. of Sci., 144 (2): 197-208.
37. Shah, A., and Shah, F. 2007. Citizen-centered Local Governance: Strategies to combat democratic deficits. Dev., 50(1): 79.
38. Silima, T. 2016. Good Governance and Conflict Resolution in Africa. J. of Public Admin. and Dev. Alternative., 1(1): 1-14.
39. Sithirith, M. 2017. Water Governance in Cambodia: From Centralized Water Governance to Farmer Water User Community. Resour., 6(44):1-20.
40. Sternlieb, F. and Laituri, M. 2015. Specializing Agricultural Water Governance Data in Polycentric Regimes. Water Alternative., 8(2): 36-56.
41. Sundbland, E. L., Biel, A., and Gärling, T. 2009. Knowledge and Confidence in Knowledge About Climate Change Among Experts, Journalists, Politicians, and Laypersons. Environ. and Behav., 41(2): 281-302.
42. Turner, R. A., Fitzsimmons , C., Forster, J., Mahon, R., Peterson, A. and Stead, M. S. 2014. Measuring Good Governance for Complex Ecosystems: Perceptions of Coral Reef-Dependent Communities in the Caribbean. Glob. Environ. Change., 29: 105- 117.
43. UNDP. 2003. The Urban Governance Initiative (UNDP–TUGI). Environ. and Urban., 15 (1): 159-170.
44. UNDP.2000.Characteristics of Good Governance the Urban Governance Initiative. (TUGI).
45. UNESCO. 2011. Principles of Good Governance at Different Water Governance Levels. Papers presented at a workshop held on 22 March 2011 in Delft, the Netherlands.
46. UN-HABITAT. 2002. The Global Campaign on Urban Governance. Concept paper, 2nd Edition, Nairobi, 3-18.
47. Virtudes, A. 2016. Goode Governance Principles in Spatial Planning at Local Scale. J. of Procedia Eng., 161: 1710-1714.
48. World Bank. 1996. The World Bank Participation Sourcebook for Reconstruction and Development. Washington, D.C. 20433. U.S.A.
49. Yazdanpanah, M., Thompson, M., Hayati, D. and Zamani, G.H. 2013a. A New Enemy at the Gate: Tackling Iran’s Water Super-crisis by way of a transition from government to governance. Prog. Dev. Stud., 13:177–194.
50. Yazdanpanah, M., Hayati, D., Zamani, G. H. and Karbalaee, F. 2013b. Water Management From Tradition to Second Modernity: An analysis of the Water Crisis in Iran. Environ. Dev. and Sustain., 15 (6): 1605-1621.
51. Yazdanpanah M., Hayati, D., Thompson M., Zamani G.H., and Monfared, N. 2014. Policy and plural responsiveness: Taking Constructive Account of the Ways in Which Iranian Farmers Think about and Behave in Relation to Water. J. of Hydrology, 514(6):347-357.
Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology
Volume 21, Issue 6
September and October 2019
Pages 1379-1393