Farmers' Preferences in Adopting Conservation Tillage Systems Considering Risk Attitudes in Bakhtegan Basin

Document Type : Original Research

Authors
Department of Agricultural Economics, College of Agriculture, Shiraz University, Shiraz, Islamic Republic of Iran.
Abstract
Conservation tillage systems have been promoted by governments in many regions of the world as an effective strategy to reduce soil and water losses caused by conventional farming practices. Considering adoption of the conservation tillage system, in addition to the uncertainty in economic aspects, the attitude of farmers is also important. To assess the risk efficiency of ‎‎five tillage ‎‎‎alternatives (Low-tillage, No-tillage, Conventional tillage, and two Rotational-tillage systems), we used Stochastic Efficiency with Respect to a Function approach for the typical wheat-corn ‎‎production system in Marvdasht, Bakhtegan Basin, Iran, using ‎‎‎four-year (2010–2014) field data set. Risk-neutral farmers’ preferred the conventional tillage method over conservation tillage methods, relying on the higher net return ‎‎of the wheat-corn rotation. However, at the higher risk-aversion degrees, the ranking of conventional tillage tended to decline rapidly and the two rotational tillage systems were preferred over other alternatives. The comparison of certainty equivalents of conservation tillage treatments indicated the ‎‎superiority of low-tillage over no-tillage at all levels of risk aversion. The results of risk premium estimation in this study revealed that providing subsidy resources is not enough to promote the adoption of conservation tillage practices, and it is necessary to support risk-averse farmers by enhancing their knowledge about the risk-efficient options.

Keywords

Subjects


Abbaspour, K. C., Faramarzi, M., Ghasemi, S. S., and Yang, H. 2009. Assessing the impact of ‎climate change on water resources in Iran. Water Resour. Res., 45(10). ‎
Abdullah, A. S. 2014. Minimum tillage and residue management increase soil water content, soil ‎organic matter and canola seed yield and seed oil content in the semiarid areas of Northern Iraq. Soil ‎Till. Res., 144: 150-155. ‎
Adusumilli, N., Wang, H., Dodla, S. and Deliberto, M. 2020. Estimating risk premiums for adopting ‎no-till and cover crops management practices in soybean production system using stochastic efficiency ‎approach. Agric. Syst., 178: 102744. ‎
Afzalinia, S. 2017. Comparison of conservation tillage with conventional tillage in wheat-corn ‎rotation. Ministry of Agriculture-Jihad, Tehran, Iran. ‎
Afzalinia, S. and Zabihi, J. 2014. Soil compaction variation during corn growing season under ‎conservation tillage. Soil Till. Res., 137: 1-6. ‎
Anderson, J. R. and Hardaker, J. B. 2003. Risk aversion in economic decision making: pragmatic ‎guides for consistent choice by natural resource managers: Risk and uncertainty in environmental and ‎natural resource economics, Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd., Cheltenham, UK.‎
Archer, D. W. and Reicosky, D. C. 2009. Economic performance of alternative tillage systems in the ‎northern Corn Belt. Agron. J., 101(2): 296-304. ‎
Bengough, A. G., McKenzie, B. M., Hallett, P. D. and Valentine, T. A. 2011. Root elongation, ‎water stress, and mechanical impedance: a review of limiting stresses and beneficial root tip traits. J. ‎Exp. Bot., 62(1): 59-68. ‎
Boyer, C. N., Lambert, D. M., Larson, J. A. and Tyler, D. D. 2018. Investment analysis of cover crop ‎and no‐tillage systems on Tennessee cotton. Agron. J., 110(1): 331-338. ‎
D’Hose, T., Ruysschaert, G., Viaene, N., Debode, J., Nest, T. V., Van Vaerenbergh, J., ... and ‎Vandecasteele, B. 2016. Farm compost amendment and non-inversion tillage improve soil quality ‎without increasing the risk for N and P leaching. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ., 225: 126-139. ‎
Fathelrahman, E. M., Ascough, J. C., Hoag, D. L., Malone, R. W., Heilman, P., Wiles, L. J. and ‎Kanwar, R. S. 2011. Economic and stochastic efficiency comparison of experimental tillage systems in ‎corn and soyabean under risk. Exp. Agric., 47(1): 111-136. ‎
Fleckenstein, M., Lythgoe, A., Lu, J., Thompson, N., Doering, O., Harden, S., ... and Prokopy, L. ‎‎2020. Crop insurance: A barrier to conservation adoption?. J. Environ. Manage., 276: 111223. ‎
Gandorfer, M., Pannell, D. and Meyer-Aurich, A. 2011. Analyzing the effects of risk and uncertainty ‎on optimal tillage and nitrogen fertilizer intensity for field crops in Germany. Agric. Syst., 104(8): 615-‎‎622. ‎
Giesler, G. G., Paxton, K. W. and Millhollon, E. P. 1993. A GSD estimation of the relative worth of ‎cover crops in cotton production systems. Journal of J. Agric. Econ., 47-56. ‎
Hardaker, J. B., Lien, G., Anderson, J. R. and Huirne, R. B. 2015. Coping with risk in agriculture: ‎Applied decision analysis. Cabi. ‎
Hardaker, J. B., Richardson, J. W., Lien, G. and Schumann, K. D. 2004. Stochastic efficiency ‎analysis with risk aversion bounds: a simplified approach. AJARE, 48(2): 253-270. ‎
Hou, X., Jia, Z., Han, Q., Li, R., Wang, W. and Li, Y. 2011. Effects of rotational tillage practices on ‎soil water characteristics and crop yields in semi-arid areas of north-west China. Soil Res., 49(7): 625-‎‎632. ‎
Jones, C. E. (2006). Soil carbon’s impact on water retention. In Soil, Carbon and Water blog. Border ‎Rivers-Gwydir CMA, Grain & Graze ‘Practical clues for pasture cropping’ workshops. ‎
Kabiri, V., Raiesi, F. and Ghazavi, M. A. 2015. Six years of different tillage systems affected ‎aggregate-associated SOM in a semi-arid loam soil from Central Iran. Soil Tillage Res., 154: 114-125. ‎
Khakbazan, M., Larney, F. J., Huang, J., Mohr, R. M., Pearson, D. C. and Blackshaw, R. E. 2017. ‎Economics of conventional and conservation practices for irrigated dry bean rotations in southern ‎Alberta. Agron. J., 109(2): 576-587. ‎
Khalili, N., Arshad, M., Farajzadeh, Z., Kächele, H. and Müller, K. 2021. Does drought affect ‎smallholder health expenditures? Evidence from Fars Province, Iran. Environ. Dev. Sustain., 23(1): 765-‎‎788.‎
Khorami, S. S., Kazemeini, S. A., Afzalinia, S. and Gathala, M. K. 2018. Changes in soil properties ‎and productivity under different tillage practices and wheat genotypes: A short-term study in ‎Iran. Sustainability, 10(9): 3273. ‎
Kouselou, M., Hashemi, S., Eskandari, I., McKenzie, B. M., Karimi, E., Rezaei, A. and Rahmati, M. ‎‎2018. Quantifying soil displacement and tillage erosion rate by different tillage systems in dryland ‎northwestern Iran. Soil Use Manag., 34(1): 48-59. ‎
Larson, J. A., Jaenicke, E. C., Roberts, R. K. and Tyler, D. D. 2001. Risk effects of alternative winter ‎cover crop, tillage, and nitrogen fertilization systems in cotton production. J. Agric. Appl. Econ., 33(3): ‎‎445-457. ‎
Leys, A., Govers, G., Gillijns, K., Berckmoes, E. and Takken, I. 2010. Scale effects on runoff and ‎erosion losses from arable land under conservation and conventional tillage: The role of residue cover. J. ‎Hydrol., 390(3-4): 143-154. ‎
Li, J., Wang, Y. K., Guo, Z., Li, J. B., Tian, C., Hua, D. W., ... and Xu, Y. 2020. Effects of ‎conservation tillage on soil physicochemical properties and crop yield in an arid Loess Plateau, ‎China. Sci. Rep., 10(1): 1-15.‎
Li, L., Dingyi, S., Xiaofang, L. and Zhide, J. 2021. Influence of peasant household differentiation ‎and risk perception on soil and water conservation tillage technology adoption-an analysis of ‎moderating effects based on government subsidies. J. Clean. Prod., 288: 125092. ‎
Lien, G., Størdal, S., Hardaker, J. B. and Asheim, L. J. 2007. Risk aversion and optimal forest ‎replanting: A stochastic efficiency study. Eur. J. Oper. Res., 181(3): 1584-1592. ‎
Monjardino, M., McBeath, T. M., Brennan, L. and Llewellyn, R. S. 2013. Are farmers in low-rainfall ‎cropping regions under-fertilising with nitrogen? A risk analysis. Agric. Syst., 116: 37-51. ‎
Mu, X., Zhao, Y., Liu, K., Ji, B., Guo, H., Xue, Z. and Li, C. 2016. Responses of soil properties, ‎root growth and crop yield to tillage and crop residue management in a wheat–maize cropping system ‎on the North China Plain. Eur. J. Agron., 78: 32-43.‎
Mustafa, R. H. 2006. Risk Management in the rain-fed sector of Sudan: case study, Gedaref area ‎Eastern Sudan (Vol. 82). Margraf. ‎
Nail, E. L., Young, D. L. and Schillinger, W. F. 2007. Government subsidies and crop insurance ‎effects on the economics of conservation cropping systems in eastern Washington. Agron. J., 99(3): ‎‎614-620. ‎
Palombi, L. and Sessa, R. 2013. Climate-smart agriculture: sourcebook. ‎
Panagos, P., Ballabio, C., Himics, M., Scarpa, S., Matthews, F., Bogonos, M., ... and Borrelli, P. ‎‎2021. Projections of soil loss by water erosion in Europe by 2050. Environ. Sci. Policy, 124: 380-392. ‎
Pittelkow, C. M., Linquist, B. A., Lundy, M. E., Liang, X., Van Groenigen, K. J., Lee, J., ... and ‎Van Kessel, C. 2015. When does no-till yield more? A global meta-analysis. Field Crops Res., 183: 156-‎‎168. ‎
Quincke, J. A., Wortmann, C. S., Mamo, M., Franti, T., Drijber, R. A. and Garcia, J. P. 2007. One‐‎time tillage of no‐till systems: Soil physical properties, phosphorus runoff, and crop yield. Agron. ‎J., 99(4): 1104-1110.‎
Roozbeh, M. and Rajaie, M. 2021. Effects of residue management and nitrogen fertilizer rates on ‎accumulation of soil residual nitrate and wheat yield under no-tillage system in south-west of Iran. Int. ‎Soil Water Conserv. Res., 9(1): 116-126. ‎
Schumann, K. D., Feldman, P. A. and Richardson, J. W. 2011. SIMETAR©: Simulation & ‎econometrics to analyze risk. College Station, TX: Agricultural and Food Policy Center, Texas A&M ‎University. ‎
TerAvest, D., Wandschneider, P. R., Thierfelder, C. and Reganold, J. P. 2019. Diversifying ‎conservation agriculture and conventional tillage cropping systems to improve the wellbeing of ‎smallholder farmers in Malawi. Agric. Syst., 171: 23-35. ‎
Tessema, Y., Asafu-Adjaye, J., Rodriguez, D., Mallawaarachchi, T. and Shiferaw, B. 2015. A bio-‎economic analysis of the benefits of conservation agriculture: The case of smallholder farmers in Adami ‎Tulu district, Ethiopia. Ecol. Econ., 120: 164-174. ‎
Townsend, T. J., Ramsden, S. J. and Wilson, P. 2016. Analysing reduced tillage practices within a ‎bio-economic modelling framework. Agric. Syst., 146: 91-102. ‎
Vetsch, J. A., Randall, G. W. and Lamb, J. A. 2007. American Society of Agronomy. Agron. J., 99: ‎‎952-959.‎
Wang, H., Adusumilli, N., Gentry, D. and Fultz, L. 2020. Economic and stochastic efficiency ‎analysis of alternative cover crop systems in Louisiana. Exp. Agric., 56(5): 651-661. ‎
Williams, J. D., Gollany, H. T., Siemens, M. C., Wuest, S. B. and Long, D. S. 2009. Comparison of ‎runoff, soil erosion, and winter wheat yields from no-till and inversion tillage production systems in ‎northeastern Oregon. J. Soil Water Conserv., 64(1): 43-52. ‎
Williams, J. R. 1988. A stochastic dominance analysis of tillage and crop insurance practices in a ‎semiarid region. Am. J. Agric. Econ., 70(1): 112-120. ‎
Yang, X. M., Drury, C. F., Reynolds, W. D. and Tan, C. S. 2008. Impacts of long-term and recently ‎imposed tillage practices on the vertical distribution of soil organic carbon. Soil Tillage Res., 100(1-2): ‎‎120-124. ‎
Zeweld, W., Van Huylenbroeck, G., Tesfay, G. and Speelman, S. 2017. Smallholder farmers' ‎behavioural intentions towards sustainable agricultural practices. J. Environ. Manage., 187: 71-81. ‎
Zhang, L., Wang, J., Fu, G. and Zhao, Y. 2018. Rotary tillage in rotation with plowing tillage ‎improves soil properties and crop yield in a wheat-maize cropping system. PLoS One, 13(6): e0198193. ‎