Application of Sensitivity Analysis in Forest Road Networks Planning and Assessment

Authors
E. Hayati
E. Abdi
B. Majnounian
M. Makhdom
Department of Forestry and Forest Economics, Faculty of Natural Resources, University of Tehran, Karaj, Islamic Republic of Iran.
Abstract
In the last few years, public awareness has been on the increase about short- and long-term effects of forest roads construction on the environment. Therefore, forest road managers have to be concerned about the negative impacts and mitigate them as much as possible. This research conducted multi-criteria analysis techniques in a useful way to define the effective criteria and propose a model for forest road network planning and assessment so that both economic and environmental costs are minimized. The model was used for evaluating the alternatives and a sensitivity analysis was then performed to verify the model. Results of sensitivity analysis showed that, there were two alternatives out of nine, with the lowest negative impacts. As a result, analytic hierarchy process and sensitivity analysis (AHP-SA) revealed that the criteria slope, soil texture and landslide susceptibility had the highest weight values, respectively, and the criteria soil texture and distance from stream networks and distance from faults were especially sensitive to the changes. In addition, the sensitivity analysis proved that the model proposed in our analysis was almost reliable and stable, and only the first and second priorities were replaced in priority levels when the weight values of criteria were changed. Results showed that the methodology was useful for identifying road networks that met environmental and cost considerations. Based on this work, the authors suggest future work in forest road planning using multi-criteria evaluation and decision making be considered in other regions and that the road planning criteria identified by the experts in this study can be useful.

Keywords

1. Abdi, E., Majnounian, B., Darvishsefat, A., Mashayekhi, Z. and Sessions, J. 2009. A GIS-MCE Based Model for Forest Road Planning. J. For. Sci., 55(4): 171-176.
2. Ahmadi, M. T., Attarod, P. and Bayramzadeh, V. 2011. Rainfall Redistribution by an Oriental Beech (Fagus orientalis Lipsky) Forest Canopy in the Caspian Forest, North of Iran. J. Agr. Sci. Tech., 13: 1045-1051.
3. Akash, B. A., Mamlook, R. and Mohsen, M. S. 1999. Multi-criteria Selection of Electric Power Plants Using Analytical Hierarchy Process. Elector. Pow. Syst. Res., 52: 29–35.
4. Akay, A. E. 2006. Minimizing Total Costs of Forest Roads with Computer-aided Design Model. Sadhana-Acad P. Eng. S., 31(5): 621-633.
5. Akay, A. E., Erdas, O., Reis, M. and Yukse, A. 2008. Estimating Sediment Yield from a Forest Road Network by Using a Sediment Prediction Model and GIS Techniques. Build. Environ., 43: 687–695.
6. Akay, A. E., Wing, M. G., Sivrikaya, F. and Sakar, D. 2012. A GIS-based Decision Support System for Determining the Shortest and Safest Route to Forest Fires: A Case Study in Mediterranean Region of Turkey. Environ. Monit. Assess., 184(3): 1391-1407.
7. Arnaez, J., Larrea, V. and Ortigosa, L. 2004. Surface Runoff and Soil Erosion on Unpaved Forest Roads from Rainfall Simulation Tests in Northeastern Spain. Catena, 57: 1–14.
8. Aruga, K. 2005. Tabu Search Optimization of Horizontal and Vertical Alignments of Forest Roads. J. For. Res., 10: 275–284.
9. Austen, E. and Hanson, A. 2008. Identifying Wetland Compensation Principles and Mechanisms for Atlantic Canada Using a Delphi Method Approach. Wetlands, 28(3): 640–655.
10. Biswas, S., Vacik, H., Swanson, M. E. and Haque, S. M. S. 2012. Evaluation Integrated Watershed Management Using Multiple Criteria Analysis: A Case Study at Chittagong Hill Tracts in Bangladesh. Environ. Monit. Assess., 184(5): 2741-2761.
11. Chan, F. T. S., Chan, M. H. and Tang, N. K. H. 2000. Evaluation Methodologies for Technology Selection. J. Mater. Process. Tech., 107: 330–337.
12. Cole, D. N. and Landres, P. B. 1996. Threats to Wilderness Ecosystems: Impacts and Research Needs. Ecol. Appl., 6: 168–84.
13. Coulter, E. D., Coakley, J. and Sessions, J. 2006. The Analytic Hierarchy Process: A Tutorial for Use in Prioritizing Forest Road Investments to Minimize Environmental Effects. Int. J. For. Eng., 17: 51–70.
14. Crosetto, M., Tarantola, S. and Saltelli, A. 2000. Sensitivity and Uncertainty Analysis in Spatial Modelling Based on GIS. Agr. Ecosys. Environ., 81(1): 71–79.
15. Curtis, I. A. 2004. Valuing Ecosystem Goods and Services: A New Approach Using a Surrogate Market and the Combination of a Multiple Criteria Analysis and a Delphi Panel to Assign Weights to Attributes. Ecol. Econ., 50: 163–94.
16. Dean, D. 1997. Finding Optimal Routes for Networks of Harvest Site Access Roads Using GIS-based Techniques. Can. J. For. Res., 27: 11–22.
17. Delgado, J. D., Arevalo, J. R. and Fernandez-Palacios, J. M. 2007. Road Edge Effect on the Abundance of the Lizard Gallotia galloti (Sauria: Lacertidae) in Two Canary Islands Forests. Biodivers. Conserv., 16: 2949–2963.
18. Demir, M. 2007. Impacts, Management and Functional Planning Criterion of Forest Road Network System in Turkey. Transport. Res. A-Pol., 41: 56–68.
19. Dutton, A. L., Loague, k. and Wemple, B. C. 2005. Road Sediment Production and Delivery: Processes and Management. Earth. Surf. Proc. Land, 30: 325-338.
20. Eastman, J. R. 2003. IDRISI for Windows Users Guide Version Kilimanjaro. Clark Labs for Cartographic Technology and Geographic Analysis, Clark University.
21. Esmailzadeh, O., Hosseini, S. M. and Tabari, M. 2011. Relationship between Soil Seed Bank and Above-ground Vegetation of a Mixed-deciduous Temperate Forest in Northern Iran. J. Agr. Sci. Tech., 13: 411-424.
22. Forman, R. T. T. and Alexander, L. E. 1998. Roads and Their Major Ecological Effects. Annu. Rev. Ecol. Syst., 29, 207–231.
23. Forman, R.T.T., Friedman, D.S., Fitzhenry, D., Martin, J.D., Chen, A.S., Alexander, L.E., 1997. Ecological Effects of roads: toward three summary indices and an overview for North America. In: Canters, K., Piepers, A., Hendriks-Heersma, D. (Eds.), Proceedings Habitat Fragmentation and Infrastructure. Ministry of Transport, Public Works and Water Management, Delft, The Netherlands, pp. 40–54.
24. Forsyth, A. R., Bubb, K. A. and Cox, M. E. 2006. Runoff, Sediment Loss and Water Quality from Forest Roads in a Southeast Queensland Coastal Plain Pinus Plantation. For. Ecol. Manag., 221(1–3): 194–206.
25. Fu, B., Newham, L. T. H. and Ramos-Scharron, C. E. 2010. A Review of Surface Erosion and Sediment Delivery Models for Unsealed Roads. Environ. Modell. Softw., 25: 1–14.
26. Gercek, H., Karpak, B. and Kilincaslan, T. 2004. A Multiple Criteria Approach for the Evaluation of the Rail Transit Networks in Istanbul. Transport., 31: 203–228.
27. Gumus, S., Acar, H. H. and Toksoy, D. 2008. Functional Forest Road Network Planning by Consideration of Environmental Impact Assessment for Wood Harvesting. Environ. Monit. Assess., 142: 109–116.
28. Hasmadi, M. and Taylor, J. C. 2008. Sensitivity Analysis of an Optimal Access Road Location in Hilly Forest Area: A GIS Approach. Am. J. Appl. Sci., 5(12): 1686-1692.
29. Heinimann, H. R. 1996. Opening-up Planning Taking into Account Environmental and Social Integrity. Proceedings of the Seminar on Environmentally Sound Forest Roads and Wood Transport, Romania, PP. 62–69.
30. Hui, C., Shuang-cheng, L. and Yi-li, Z. 2003. Impact of Road Construction on Vegetation Alongside Qinghal-Xizang Highway and Railway. Chin. Geogr. Sci., 13 (4): 340-346.
31. Keeney, R. L. and Raiffa, H. 1976. Decisions with Multiple Objectives: Preferences and Value Tradeoffs. J. Wiley, New York, 569 P.
32. Larsen, M. C. and Parks, J. E. 1997. How Wide Is a Road? The Association of Roads and Mass-wasting in a Forested Mountain Environment. Earth. Surf. Proc. Land, 22: 835-848.
33. Loo, R. 2002. The Delphi Method: A Powerful Tool for Strategic Management. Policing, 25(4): 762-769.
34. Lugoa, A. and Gucinski, E. 2000. Function, Effects, and Management of Forest Roads. For. Ecol. Manag., 133: 249–262.
35. Malczewski, J. 2006. GIS-based Multicriteria Decision Analysis: A Survey of the Literature. Int. J. Geogr. Inf. Syst., 20(7): 703–726.
36. Marinoni, O. 2004. Implementation of the Analytical Hierarchy Process with VBA in ArcGIS. Comput. Geosci., 30: 637–646.
37. Mészáros, C.S. and Rapcsák, T. 1996. On Sensitivity Analysis for a Class of Decision Systems. Decis. Support. Syst., 16: 231–240.
38. Pasqualini, V., Oberti, P., Vigetta, S., Riffard, O., Panaiotis, C., Cannac, M. and Ferrat, L. 2011. A GIS-Based Multicriteria Evaluation for Aiding Risk Management Pinus pinaster Ait. Forests: A Case Study in Corsican Island, Western Mediterranean Region. Environ. Manag., 48: 38–56.
39. Pukkala, T. 2002. Multi-objective Forest Planning: Managing Forest Ecosystems. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, 207PP.
40. Rogers, L. 2005. Automating Contour-based Route Projection for Preliminary Forest Road Designs Using GIS. MSc. Thesis, Washington, University of Washington, 87 PP.
41. Saaty, T. L. 1980. The Analytical Hierarchy Process, Planning Priority, Resource Allocation. McGraw-Hill, New York, USA. 287 p.
42. Saaty, T. L. 2000. Decision Making for Leaders. RWS Publications, Pittsburgh, PA, 323 PP.
43. Sadeghi-Niaraki, A., Varshosaz, M., Kim, K. and Jung, J. J. 2011. Real World Representation of a Road Network for Route Planning in GIS. Expert Syst. Appl., 38 (10): 11999-12008
44. Sadeghi Ravesh, M. H., Ahmadi, H. and Zehtabian, G. 2011. Application of Sensitivity Analysis for Assessment of De-desertification Alternatives in the Center of Iran by Using Traintaphyllou Method. Environ. Monit. Assess., 179(1-4): 31-46.
45. Samani, J. M. V. and Solimani, A. 2008. Uncertainty Analysis of Routed Outflow in Rockfill Dams. J. Agr. Sci. Tech., 10: 55-66.
46. Sener, S., Sener, E. and Karaguzel, R. 2011. Solid Waste Disposal Site Selection with GIS and AHP Methodology: A Case Study in Senirkent-Uluborlu (Isparta) Basin, Turkey. Environ. Monit. Assess., 173(1-4): 533-554.
47. Shiba, M. 1995. Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) Based Multi Attribute Benefit Structure Analysis of Road Network System in Mountainous Rural Areas of Japan. Int. J. For. Eng., 7: 14–50.
48. Steinmüller, T. 2003. Evaluation of the Social and Economic Benefits of Subsidized Forest Road Developments in Austria. In: Proceedings of the Austro2003 Meeting: High Tech Forest Operations for Mountainous Terrain, CD ROM, Limbeck-Lilienau, Steinmüller and Stampfer (Editors), October 5-9 2003, Schlaegl–Austria, 10 PP.
49. Taylor, R. N. 1984. Behavioral Decision Making. Glenview, Scott-Foresman, IL.
50. Taylor, J. G. and Ryder, S. D. 2003. Use of the Delphi Method in Resolving Complex Water Resources Issues. J. Am. Water Resour. As., 39:183–189.
51. Tudes, S. and Yigiter, N.D. 2010. Preparation of Land Use Planning Model Using GIS Based on AHP: Case Study Adana-Turkey. Bull. Eng. Geol. Environ., 69: 235–245.
52. Vadrevu, K. P., Eaturu, A. and Badarinath, K. V. S. 2010. Fire Risk Evaluation Using Multi-criteria Analysis: A Case Study. Environ. Monit. Assess., 166(1-4): 223-239.
Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology
Volume 15, Issue 4
July and August 2013
Pages 781-792